Close Menu
    Support Us
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
    • About
    • Authors
    • Store
    • Spanish
    • Contact
    Al Jumuah MagazineAl Jumuah Magazine
    • Home
    • Quran
      • Commentary
      • Sciences
    • Sunnah
      • commentary
      • Sciences
    • Character
    • Advice
      • Family
      • Society
    • Thoughts
    • Discover islam
    • Hajj FAQs
    HAJJ
    Support Us
    Al Jumuah MagazineAl Jumuah Magazine
    Home»Advice»Can We Really Judge a 7th-Century Man by Today’s Standards?
    Advice knowthyprophet Society Thoughts

    Can We Really Judge a 7th-Century Man by Today’s Standards?

    Salma ChaudharyBy Salma Chaudhary10 Mins Read
    Share
    Facebook Twitter WhatsApp Pinterest LinkedIn Email

    Every generation has measured Prophet Muhammad ﷺ against the particular anxieties of its own age. Medieval Christendom measured him against its own code of chivalry. Colonial-era scholars measured him against Victorian propriety. We measure him, mostly without noticing we are doing it, against the instincts of modern liberal secularism. The question deserves to be asked plainly rather than argued around: can a man who lived fourteen centuries ago, in a part of Arabia most modern readers can barely picture, be called morally good by the standards we hold today? It is a fair question, and it deserves something better than silence or reflex.

    Answering it honestly takes two steps. First, we must ask whether it even makes sense to judge a figure from one century by the moral language of a much later one. Only once that question is settled does it make sense to look at what he actually did — using the earliest and most carefully verified sources, not the distorted outlines that circulate in online arguments.

    The Trap of Assuming the Newer Is Truer

    C.S. Lewis gave a name to a mistake most of us make without realizing it: “chronological snobbery”, the quiet assumption that an older idea, or an older person, must be worse simply for being old. Follow that assumption to its end and it collapses under its own weight. If morality is nothing more than whatever a given century agrees on, our own century’s most confident judgments are just as temporary as anyone else’s, and people three hundred years from now will have every right to wince at positions we currently treat as obvious. This is not a hypothetical. We have already watched it happen, within living memory. Societies that considered themselves enlightened defended slavery as civilization rather than its opposite well into the 1800s. Factories built on child labor were celebrated as progress. Eugenics was respectable academic science less than a hundred years ago, championed by people we otherwise remember as reformers. Once that pattern becomes visible, the conclusion is hard to avoid: if “moral” simply means whatever most people currently believe, no era has real standing to judge another, including our own.

    A sturdier measure looks for what holds up across cultures that never touched one another at all: honesty, mercy, protecting the weak, keeping one’s word, restraint even where cruelty would be easy. That these principles keep showing up independently, in civilizations with no shared history, suggests they are tracking something real rather than simply reflecting the fashion of a particular time and place. So the fair question to ask of the Prophet ﷺ is not whether he happened to agree with every position a 21st-century reformer holds, but something closer to the ground: did he move his own society measurably toward more justice and more mercy, using what was actually available to him at the time? That is a question his life can answer, not merely a claim his admirers can assert.

    What He Actually Changed

    Picture the world he was born into. Pre-Islamic Arabia buried infant daughters alive. It fought tribal wars with no real limit on what could be done to the defeated. Its lending practices trapped the poor in debt they could never work their way out of. It had no developed sense of caring for orphans, and none at all of extending rights to the enslaved. Over twenty-three years, each of these was dismantled.

    He ended the burying of infant girls, a practice so deeply normalized that undoing it required direct revelation rather than persuasion alone. The Qur’an describes a reckoning on the Day of Judgment, when

    “the girl [who was] buried alive is asked, for what sin she was killed.” [Surah al-Takwir, 81:8–9]

    He secured women’s legal right to inherit, in a world where women themselves were sometimes treated as property to be inherited rather than people entitled to inherit. He placed real limits on warfare—no killing of civilians, no destroying crops, no desecrating the dead—limits the modern laws of war would only formalize for the rest of the world centuries later. And standing before tens of thousands at his final public sermon, addressing a culture that measured a person’s worth almost entirely by lineage, he said plainly,

    “There is no superiority of an Arab over a non-Arab, nor a non-Arab over an Arab, nor a white person over a black one, nor a black one over a white one, except by righteousness.” (Ahmad)

    He described his own mission, in the Qur’an’s own words, as being sent

    “as a mercy to all the worlds.” [Surah al-Anbiya’, 21:107]

    Whatever one makes of the theological claim behind that verse, it is difficult to find a better one-line summary of the pattern his life actually shows, again and again, including at the moments when mercy would have been easiest to set aside.

    The same instinct shows up in his practical decisions. One of his first acts after settling in Madinah was drafting what historians now call the Constitution of Madinah, a treaty that gave the city’s Jewish tribes formal legal protection and religious freedom as genuine partners in the new community, not subjects tolerated at its edges. Pluralism on that scale had almost no precedent anywhere in the world at the time.

    None of this required him to think like a modern reformer. It required him to be dramatically, measurably better than the world immediately around him, pulling it toward justice through methods his own people could actually recognize and accept.

    What He Did With Total Power

    The real test of anyone’s character comes at the moment they finally hold complete power and nothing is left to restrain them.

    When he returned to conquer Makkah—the city that had exiled him, starved his followers to the edge of death, tortured early converts, and fought him outright for over a decade—he took it without spilling a drop of blood, then declared a sweeping amnesty for the very people responsible for all of it. Hind bint Utbah, who had mutilated his uncle’s body after a battle, was pardoned. So was the man who had actually killed him. Conquests of that era did not usually end this way, and the earliest historians recorded the episode precisely because its restraint was so unusual, even by the standards of their own time.

    The pattern reaches back further still, to the years before he was ever a Prophet to anyone. The people of Makkah, including men who later became his bitterest enemies, called him al-Amin, the Trustworthy, because he was the one people handed their valuables to for safekeeping. A reputation like that is not built in a single moment. It accumulates slowly, in small, ordinary transactions, among people who had no particular reason to be generous in their judgment of him.

    The Hard Questions, Met Honestly

    Three objections come up constantly, and each one deserves a real answer rather than a reflexive dismissal.

    His marriage to A’ishah: By the standards of 7th-century Arabia—and, for that matter, by the standards of most agrarian societies well into the modern era, including parts of Europe surprisingly recently—the age involved was not considered unusual for its time. That is not an argument that the practice would satisfy today’s standards. It is a reminder that judging a 7th-century marriage by the law of 2026 repeats the very mistake the opening of this piece already warned against. What actually matters for judging character is not the calendar but the nature of the relationship itself, whether it was marked by cruelty or by warmth. The testimony that survives, extensive and drawn directly from A’ishah, describes real affection and real intellectual partnership. She went on to become one of the most significant scholars in early Islamic history, a woman whose legal rulings senior Companions sought out long after his death. That is not the trajectory of someone who was merely controlled.

    Banu Qurayza: This is the hardest case, and it deserves honesty rather than a clever way around it. Context matters enormously here: this was a tribe that broke a mutual defense treaty during the Battle of the Trench, at the exact moment the entire Muslim community in Madinah faced the real possibility of being wiped out. The ruling that followed came from an arbitrator, Sa’d ibn Mu’adh, chosen at Qurayza’s own request from among their own historical allies, applying the established laws of war for a besieged and treacherous ally; standards with real parallels elsewhere in the region’s legal traditions, including the Torah’s own rules for a besieged city (Deuteronomy 20:10–14). It is also true that the Prophet ﷺ accepted and carried out that ruling, and is reported to have told Sa’d afterward that he had judged them “by the judgment of God from above seven heavens,” a hadith scholars have graded authentic. So the honest defense here is narrower than simply saying he had nothing to do with it. This was a wartime legal judgment, issued under an existential threat, by an arbitrator both sides had agreed to; later affirmed rather than personally imposed. That is a real distinction.

    Slavery: He was born into a world where every major civilization practiced it without exception. He did not abolish it by decree, and that is worth saying plainly rather than explaining away. Such a decree likely would have been as unenforceable in 7th-century Arabia as it proved difficult to enforce even in 19th-century America. What he set in motion instead was a slow, deliberate campaign to make freeing people the normal moral instinct of the community. “They are your brothers,” he said of those held in bondage.

    “Allah has placed them under your authority. So whoever has his brother under his authority, let him feed him from what he eats, and clothe him from what he wears.” (al-Bukhari)

    Freeing a slave became one of the most rewarded acts a believer could perform, and it became the prescribed way of making amends for a wide range of sins. That trajectory pointed unmistakably toward abolition, and it was one Islamic law kept building on for centuries, well ahead of most of the rest of the world.

    Not Only the Faithful Have Said So

    A handful of historians working entirely outside the Islamic tradition, with no religious stake in the outcome, reached strikingly similar conclusions once they actually examined the record. Thomas Carlyle thought the popular European caricature of him as a fraud was simply untenable, arguing that no one fakes their way into transforming an entire civilization. Lamartine, writing in 19th-century France, marveled that a man with no inherited wealth, no army, and no political office at the start achieved what he did. Montgomery Watt, after decades of critical historical study, never seriously doubted the man’s sincerity, whatever theological disagreement remained with his message. None of this amounts to a consensus, earlier generations of Western scholarship often reached far harsher verdicts, and that argument is still alive today. But it is worth knowing that the more admiring assessments have not come only from inside the faith.

    A Fair Verdict

    If moral goodness means perfectly anticipating every ethical conclusion a distant future century will eventually reach, no one in history passes that test, not anyone. But if it means having the courage to confront one’s own society’s worst habits, showing real mercy to people who had earned none, being the same person in private as in public, and leaving the world measurably more just than one found it, then the honest answer, based on the earliest and most reliable record available, is yes. Not because that record is free of hard questions, it is not, and this piece has tried to meet its hardest moments directly rather than pass over them. But because, judged by the only standard that can fairly be applied to anyone, the case holds up far better than his critics usually admit, and rests on firmer ground than admiration alone could ever provide.

    ethics judging Mohammad morality Muhammad Prophet
    Previous ArticleFour Billion Years of the Earth’s History Summarized by Prophet Muhammad
    Next Article Islamic Views of TAHRIF and Orthodox Judaism’s View Of ORAL LAW
    Salma Chaudhary

    Related Posts

    An Islamic View of Peaceful Coexistence | Part 2

    By Jaafir Idris
    Read More

    How Abraham Initiated Globalization

    By Omar Abdl-Haleem
    Read More

    An Islamic View of Peaceful Coexistence | Part 1

    By Jaafir Idris
    Read More

    The Final Return | Part 2

    By Mohammed Siraj Uddin
    Read More

    The Sublime Quran and the Weight of its Revelation (Wahi) upon our Prophet

    By Sajida Fakhri
    Read More

    Why Allah Does Not Change a People’s Condition Until They Change Themselves

    By Al Jumuah Staff
    Read More
    Leave A Reply Cancel Reply

    This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

    Recent Comments
    • Muzammil on Zukhraful Qawlal Ghuroor – When Sins Are Beautifully Presented, Deception is Easy: “Clear”
    • qassim ouma akoko on Monotheistic Pilgrimage: The Ka’bah and Bait Al-Muqaddas / Beit HaMiqdash: “be blessed”
    • Abubakar on Having Guests? Host from the Heart – Caring with Islamic Etiquette: “A beautiful reminder that true hospitality in Islam is not about luxury, but about kindness, generosity, and sincere care for…”
    • A Muslim man on Unveiling The Hûr Al-‘În | Part 1: “Okay, look men are creepy and most of you women don’t have to deal with men in Jannah so the…”
    • Jacqui DeLorenzo on The Spirituality of Ramadan and Fasting: “This is a deeply thoughtful and enriching exploration of the spirituality of Ramadan and fasting. I truly appreciate how the…”
    Menu
    • About
    • Contact
    • Authors
    • Spanish
    • Store
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
    Copyright © 2026 Al Jumuah Magazine

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.

    ALJUMUAH MAGAZINE

    🌙

    Assalamu Alaikum!

    Stay Connected With AlJumuah

    Receive Islamic reminders, Quran and Sunnah reflections, and the latest updates from AlJumuah.

    Message us on WhatsApp to receive our official channel link.



    Say Hi on WhatsApp

    Free to connect • Opens WhatsApp